Top 10 Best Broiler Pans To Buy 2023

The best broiler pan will bring you the healthiest dishes. A conventional broiler pan is designed for use in the oven, and it ensures that all of a food’s vitamins, nutrients, and minerals remain intact during cooking.

In general, the broiler pan is specially made to broil food, giving the food a crisp brown color similar to what you would get when cooking on the grill.

The broiler pan’s specialty is that it reflects the heat from the top down and ensures that the dish is cooked evenly in all parts. For the perfectionist in cooking, the broiler pan is one of the best choices.

To make it simple for you, I have round up the best broiler pans for you in 2023. I’ll also give you a comprehensive guide to the best broiler pan types along with how to choose the right one.

Structure Of A Broiler Pan

A typical broiler pan consists of two different part – the drip tray and the bottom pan.

• The drip tray is constructed with a multi-grooved surface to release oil, grease, excess juice and fat out of your food.
• The bottom pan is designed with a flat surface to reflect heat and catch the water from food when cooking.

Material Classification Of The Broiler Pans

Despite the same structure, the broiler pan is diverse in materials. To make it easier to learn about this kitchen tool, you can classify them according to the following materials:

• Steel: Broiler pan can be made of carbon steel and stainless steel. This is a very durable material that does not rust and is highly resistant to impact damage. It can be used on many different cookers. This type is also safe in the oven with high temperature.
• Aluminum: This is the best heat transfering material and is also extremely durable. It is also suitable for use on a variety of furnaces.
• Porcelain: Not only has the excellent anti-stick ability, but porcelain broiler pans also has excellent scratch resistance to keep the pan looking new.
• Ceramic: This is the material commonly used to coat the non-stick surface for broiler pan. It does not contain harmful substances and is also very anti-stick.

Despite their similar look, ceramic and porcelain are not completely the same. You should be able to differentiate between ceramic and porcelain kitchenware to decide which product is more suitable for you.

The Benefits Of Having The Best Broiler Pan

If you are looking for the best broiler pan to buy for your family, let me give you a little encouragement by stating the advantages you will have when buying this product:

Long-Time Use

A good broiler pan will last for many years. You won’t be forced to replace it and can use it to make many delicious dishes for a long time. 

Time-Saving

A good broiler pan with good heat retention will take a short time to cook your food. Compared to deep frying or boiling, which takes the time to heat up cooking oil and water, respectively, this cooking method is faster.

Even Cooking

A quality broiler pan will cook your meals evenly. High-quality broiler pans are made of premium materials. Whether it’s aluminum, steel, carbon steel, or even ceramic clay, a good broiler pan radiates heat evenly.

Money-Saving

The broiler pan will speed up your cooking time, and you can cook the meat with the minimum amount of oil. Hence, this kind of pan will save your money and also reflect positively on your health.

Popular Brands Of The Best Broiler Pan

In addition to the above factors, finding a reliable brand is also important when buying a broiler pan. Currently, there are some prestigious brands, such as:

Granite Ware

Famous for its steel core pans that provide strength and even heat distribution while the porcelain surface is naturally inert and nonstick. The material is completely natural and will not change your food’s color, taste, or nutritional value.

Nordic Ware

From limited edition pans to microwave cookware, many Nordic Ware’s products are proudly made in the United States.

Range Kleen

A company that provides cleaning services, cookware, kitchen accessories, utensils, and other related products. Range Kleen serves customers in the United States.

Wilton

As a famous company in the market, Wilton specializes in providing a range of household appliances, including pan series from pans specifically designed for stir-frying, broiler pans to baking pans that are extremely convenient and durable for consumers.

Which Are The Best Broiler Pans To Buy?

This year, the best broiler pans are Granite Ware and Nordic Ware, with their excellent thermal distribute ability as well as their nonstick surface. They also do a great job of removing excess oil for a healthy meal. Besides, the Range Kleen is also a perfect broiler pan thanks to its durable steel core.

Let’s take a look at this year’s best broiler pans with their features below:

• Best Overall: Granite Ware 0513-2 3-Piece Broiler Pan
  “Excellent heat retention properties, versatile for cooking, free from harmful chemicals, large cooking space, evenly distributed heat, effective anti-stick feature, release the fat and excess oil.”
• Best Budget: Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan
  “Compact size, easy to prepare meals everywhere, convenient and lightweight to move quickly, friendly outdoor cooking stove, easy storage, and affordable price.”
• Best Porcelain: Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Steel Broiler Pan
  “Grilling design suitable for healthy cooking, versatile to broil and roast, compatible with outdoor cooking, convenient size to move, good anti-stick ability, and enduring finish.”
• Best Nonstick: Nordic Ware 41831 Nonstick Broiler Pan
  “Distribute heat quickly and evenly, anti-stick feature, a drip tray to collect excess oil, fashionable design, durable finish, last for a long time, easy to clean and maintain, healthy cooking.”
• Best for Oven: G & S Metal Products OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan
  “Suitable for all oven, nonstick surface, three functions in one, durable heavyweight steel material, large broil surface, drip tray to collect excess oil, and distributing heat evenly.”
• Best for Gas Stove: Frigidaire 5304442087 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
  “High thermal resistivity, long and wide top tray, good for excess oil drain, nonstick ceramic surface, no harmful chemicals, convenient size, and smooth cooking surface.”
• Best Large: General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan
  “Industrial grade steel structure, nonstick protective coating, easy vent mechanism, large cooking surface, suitable for preparing large meals, collect excess oil, distributes heat quickly and evenly.”
• Best Small: Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
  “Durable stainless steel material, dripped upper tray, compact cooking surface, dual function, designed for healthy cooking, stable and robust construction.”
• Best Steel: Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan
  “Ideal for most standard ovens, easy to use with large handle, nonstick and anti-wrap, durable, heavy-duty steel, remove excess oil, and safe in the dishwashers.”
• Best Disposable: DCS Deals Disposable 15-Piece Broiler Pan
  “Oven-safe, fridge-safe and freezer-safe, ribbed bottom, can be recycled, suitable for camping or traveling, light but sturdy, no spills, splashes, or leaks and no need for cleaning.”

Broiler Pan Comparison Table 2023

Now that you know some general things about these broiler pans, it’s time to explore the 10 different options available on the market in the comparison panel below:

Top 10 Best Broiler Pan Reviews in 2023

When buying kitchenwares such as stir-frying pans, woks made from carbon steel, baking pans, or specialized pans for sautéing, you all need to of their features, pros, and cons. So let me go through the details of each best broiler pan this year so you can make the right choice!

1. Granite Ware 0513-2 3-Piece Broiler Pan

(Best Overall)

Are you looking for a traditional broiler pan? Granite Ware 0513-2 3-Piece Broiler Pan is an ideal cookware for steaming fish, meat, poultry, or vegetables.

Granite Ware Pans are made of a three-layer metal structure and have a carbon steel core and two aluminum layers for added durability. This core property also creates the uniform heat distribution and superior browning properties of Granite Ware.

The exterior of this oven and baking pan is lined with porcelain enamel. This gives it durable nonstick properties. And because this pan is not sticky, you can cook with confidence, as cleaning will be easy.

Besides, what makes this pan even more impressive is that it’s bigger and deeper. Therefore, it’s perfect for baking food longer, and its slots allow excess fat to escape from the food.

In addition, Granite Ware is sold as a set of three pieces. The great thing about these individual items is that you can combine them together to form a dynamic trio. These pans are durable and will definitely last for a lifetime.

Key Features:

• Set of 3: Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan
• Commercial grade carbon steel core
• Nonstick porcelain enamel
• No PFOA and PTFE
• Size is suitable for all types of oven
• Perforated tray for vegetables and fish
• Made in USA
• Limited lifetime warranty: free from defects in material and workmanship

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	15.81 x 10.06 x 2.88 inches
Weight	2.9 pounds
Color	Black
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	Granite Ware

2. Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan

(Best Budget)

For an affordable price, the Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan boasts a fantastic design that can rival even products of the highest quality from Scanpan, a brand well-known for its superior kitchenwares.

The materials of the Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan are lightweight and non-sticking. The large cooking surface gives you considerable space to prepare snacks and small dishes.

In addition, the Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan’s lightweight facilitates outdoor cooking and portability. Whatever savory snacks you can come up with, the Nordic Ware 2-Piece Broiler Set is just right for them.

Furthermore, the Nordic Ware 2-Piece Broiler Set is also quite durable, and it’s not too difficult to maintain. Due to the small size, the cleaning process is easier for you.

Key Features:

• Can be used in the toaster oven, outdoor gas or electric grill
• Anti-stick feature
• Suitable for oven
• Ideal for outdoor entertainment cooking
• Suitable for preparing snacks

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	10 x 7 x 0.63 inches
Weight	9.6 pounds
Color	Metallic gold
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	No
Brand	Nordic Ware

3. Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Steel Broiler Pan

(Best Porcelain)

Range Kleen Porcelain Broiler Pan comes with two parts, namely pans and baking rack. The material is made of reinforced porcelain steel, so whether it’s meat, vegetables, or fish, the Range Kleen Porcelain Broiler Pan is suitable for all cooking.

Besides, having a grill helps to remove excess fat from the meat, meaning healthy cooking. Alternatively, you can use the Range Kleen Porcelain Broiler Pan as a grill to bake some of your favorite savory or sweet treats.

Moreover, also design and material are suitable for both indoor and outdoor cooking according to your choice. In addition to being flexible, you can clean it easily and conveniently because Range Kleen Porcelain Broiler Pan is dishwasher safe.

This video will show you some information about this broiler pan:

Key Features:

• Suitable for both outdoor and indoor cooking
• Ideal for meat, fish, and vegetables
• Ceramic pan and grill rack
• OEM quality materials

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	12.75 x 8.5 x 1.33 inches
Weight	1 pound
Color	Black
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	Range Kleen

4. G & S Metal Products OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan

(Best for Oven)

With the G & S Metal Products OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan, you can both broil, roast and bake. With its large size, you can use it for quick, easy, and reliable cooking.

Both the broiler and the Fat-A-Way drip tray of this product are manufactured from heavy-duty carbon steel. That means they are both sturdy, durable, and resistant to warping.

Incredibly as its name suggests, this G & S Metal Products OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan Set is safe with all ovens, so you can enjoy cooking with this set.

Furthermore, the G & S Metal Products OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan has a DuraGlide Plus non-stick coating surface that is easy to clean. It comes with the drip tray to help keep your food less oily.

Key Features:

• Three functions in one: broil, roast and bake
• Suitable for all ovens
• DuraGlide Plus non-stick coating
• Carbon steel is very durable

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	6.5 x 1.75 x 8.5 inches
Weight	15.2 pounds
Color	Gray
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	No
Brand	G & S Metal Products Company

5. Frigidaire 5304442087 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan

(Best for Gas Stove)

This special Frigidaire 5304442087 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan will not disappoint you in terms of utility and some great features. It has a thick nonstick ceramic surface convenient for quality meal cooking on a gas stove or oven, while also providing a smooth cooking surface for you.

In fact, this particular feature makes the Frigidaire 5304442087 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan quite suitable for cleaning the product properly. Hence, you will not have to worry about its maintenance issues.

Besides, the Frigidaire 5304442087 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan has two specific parts: the top tray and the broil pan. You can also cook meat, vegetables, chicken, and fish with these pans on the gas stove or in the oven. Its size is suitable for medium-size meat processing.

Manufactured with a stainless steel core, this Frigidaire 5304442087 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan is quite durable. The pan also has no chemicals, so this item is safe to come into contact with your food.

This item has high heat resistance. So you can use it on the stove or in the oven. Resists warping, and with its ability to quickly and evenly distribute heat, you’ll get great results.

Don’t wait to watch this video to see how this broiler pan works on the stove and oven:

Key Features:

• Suitable for gas stove, range, and oven
• High thermal resistivity
• Long and wide top tray good for the excess oil drain
• Nonstick ceramic surface
• Drip tray to collect excess oil
• No harmful chemicals

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	15.8 x 12.6 x 2.3 inches
Weight	2.5 pounds
Color	Blue
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	Frigidaire

6. General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan

(Best Large)

General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan is designed so that you can easily heat up to 500F thanks to the high strength because the core is manufactured in industrial-grade steel. Outside is nonstick ceramic. This combination gives you a quick and even heat distribution.

Besides, the upper part of the pan is serrated. The pan above is made in a vent-like slot to properly drain the oil and provide you with healthier meals all the time.

Furthermore, the General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan’s large surface is suitable for large foods, such as the whole turkey. You can also use the drip tray for baking.

General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan works best with General Electric ovens. However, we found no harm in using it with other medium-sized ovens.

The cleaning process is quite easy for the General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan. It is dishwasher safe, and you don’t need to wash it by hand.

Key Features:

• Heat up to 500F
• Industrial grade steel structure
• Nonstick protective coating on cooking surfaces
• Easy vent mechanism
• Large cooking surface

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	16.75 x 12.62 x 1.37 inches
Weight	0.01 pounds
Color	Gray
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	General electric

7. Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan

(Best Small)

Are you looking for a healthy cooking broiler pan? Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan can help. When you purchase the Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan, you get two pans per pack. Therefore, it serves both broil and roast functions.

Both pans are manufactured using very durable stainless steel. Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pans are also intelligently designed with a perforated top. That means that the grease is released to reduce fat while cooking.

With the Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan’s compact size, you can cook enough meals for one or two servings. You can prepare dishes with chicken, fish, meat, bread, and even fish with shells.

Moreover, the material of Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broiler Pan is a safe and really durable dishwasher.

Key Features:

• Suitable for chicken, fish, meat and bread broil
• Durable stainless steel material
• Dripped upper tray
• Compact cooking surface

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	12 x 9 x 1.5 inches
Weight	1.31 pounds
Color	Silver
Nonstick	No
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	Norpro

8. Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan

(Best Steel)

If you are an amateur in cooking, then you should probably consider purchasing this Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan Kit. Not only simple to use, but this broiler pan is also exceptionally functional.

The size of the Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan is ideal for most standard ovens. You only need to put all the meat, vegetables, and fish on top and put your food in the oven.

Primarily, the Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan is made of heavy gauge steel, which makes it quite strong. Therefore, it is also safe for the dishwasher.

In addition, the Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan also has slots on the bottom where all the oil, juice, crumbs, and fat fall off while your food is cooking for a healthy meal.

Additionally, the Wilton Nonstick Steel Broiler Pan incorporates an extra-large handle, making it easy to pull the tray out of the oven when your food is ready. Another great thing is that it comes with a 5-year limited warranty.

Key Features:

• An easy-to-use two-tray set
• Ideal for most standard ovens
• Large handles
• Comes with a 5-year limited warranty

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	13.25 x 2.23 x 7.98 inches
Weight	12.3 pounds
Color	Black & Silver
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	Wilton

9. DCS Deals Disposable 15-Piece Broiler Pan

(Best Disposable)

Looking for the disposable broiler pan when traveling or simply because of lazy washing? DCS Deals Disposable 15-Piece Broiler Pan will help you out.

When purchasing DCS Deals Disposable 15-Piece Broiler Pan, you will receive this bundle of 15 economical broiler pans. This foil sheet is designed for grilling any type of meat and not cause clutter on the barbecue.

Moreover, you can also use it as a drip pan to grill fish and vegetables. The textured ribbed bottom surface will give your food authentic baking.

That’s because the DCS Deals Disposable 15-Piece Broiler Pan is made of lightweight yet sturdy foil, which makes cooking fun for everyone. Food tastes great, and cleaning is even easier; just throw it in the trash.

Furthermore, you can use DCS Deals Disposable 15-Piece Broiler Pan for any oven type. You can then place the disposable drip pan in the refrigerator or freezer for later use.

Key Features:

• A package of 15 disposable broiler pans economical
• Made of aluminum
• Oven-safe, fridge-safe, and freezer-safe
• Ribbed bottom
• Can be recycled

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	13.19 x 10.08 x 2.99 inches
Weight	14.4 pounds
Color	Silver
Nonstick	No
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	DCS Deals

10. Nordic Ware 41831 Nonstick Broiler Pan

(Best Nonstick)

Nordic Ware 41831 Nonstick Broiler Pan is another excellent dual option. The set comes with a set of two pieces to broil meat, vegetables, and chicken.

To facilitate more variety in your cooking options, the Nordic Ware 41831 Nonstick Broiler Pan has a ribbed broil rack and a versatile drip broil pan.

Not only made of carbon steel, but the core also has two layers of aluminum. With both pans manufactured with three layers, the Nordic Ware 41831 Nonstick Broiler Pan has a longer lifespan.

This also allows for faster heating as these metals are large conductors of heat. They also distribute heat evenly, so you cook your best all the time.

Besides, the broil rack of this pan has ribs to drain excess oil. Both pans are nonstick, allowing for easy release of food and subsequent cleaning.

Key Features:

• Three-layer structure with a carbon core between two layers of aluminum
• Absorbs and retains heat quickly
• Suitable for mounting in all common ovens
• Excess fat removal slot
• Provide for the side handle
• The size is just right

Product Specifications:

Dimensions	15.8 x 9.8 x 1.3 inches
Weight	2.24 pounds
Color	Black
Nonstick	Yes
Dishwasher safe	Yes
Brand	Nordic Ware

Things To Consider – How To Buy The Best Broiler Pan

Knowing the best broiler pans is not enough, you also have to consider many factors to find the most suitable for your individual need. Let’s take a look at some points you should think about:

Material

Broiler pan material is important. Different materials have different heating, warming, and holding properties. The four most common materials you’ll find in every cookware are stainless steel, ceramic, aluminum, and carbon steel.

The ingredients will also show if you can cook healthy and manage heat effectively and whether it’s safe for cooking.

Different materials have different pros and cons, and you just need to find the one that works best for you.

Nonstick Surface

The non-stickiness of the surface is also important. If you don’t want to struggle with a broiler pan full of post-cooked food or your beautiful dishes crumble, opt for an effective nonstick pan.

In addition, your nonstick layer must also be scratch-resistant and anti-peeling for the most durable use.

Size

The size determines whether or not the broiler pan will fit in the oven you are using. Besides, the cooking surface area it provides is also important.

The small broiler pan is easy to transport but not suitable for cooking a large meal. Therefore, you need to decide which specific features you need to prioritize.

Easy To Clean

Cleaning is a nuisance for everyone, and we tend to avoid it all the time. For the broiler pan, cleaning is not just a matter of convenience here. Hygiene is also very important for consuming safe food.

Most broiler pans are guaranteed dishwasher safety. But in fact, this can affect the lifespan of the broiler pan. The products are probably dishwasher safe, but it’s better to wash them by hand for the best possible results.

Flexible

There are some broiler pans suitable only for meat processing. Other dishes are only suitable for snacks while there are other dishes where you can cook pretty much anything.

If you’re looking for a broiler pan to cook meat only, you can limit your search. But if you want more, you should learn about its features.

Durable

Some broiler pan may look nice but not as durable as you might expect. Our general recommendation is that you choose something for sure.

You want to invest in a corrosion-resistant broiler pan. It must also be able to withstand premature wear.

And if you plan to use it in a dishwasher, it must be certified as safe for use under such conditions. You don’t want to end up with a broiler pan that will crack if exposed to such conditions.

Type Of Food

The broiler pan is commonly used to process vegetables or meat – but mostly meat. In case you are specifically looking for them to prepare meat, you should emphasize a few basics.

First, you must make sure that the broiler pan comes with the grill rack. In addition, the presence of a complete mesh sheet with wide slots can help ensure that grease flows smoothly.

If you plan to prepare some vegetables, you may find it beneficial to choose a wide-surface broiler pan, especially on its top rack.

The Best Ways To Clean A Broiler Pan

Before using your broiler pan to broil the next piece of food, you need to clean it. Not any washing method gives you the best results. But you can use the following tips to make sure your broiler pan shines:

• Use soap: You cannot confirm that a broiler pan is clean without soap. Apply a sufficient amount of soap and rub to remove the grease layer.
• Use hot water: You will not be able to get rid of cooking oils that contain animal fat without hot water. You can use hot water to clean and disinfect the broiler pan.
• Use of baking soda: It has been shown that baking soda can remove stubborn stains on many cooking utensils. You will love the result using it on your broiler pan. You need to pour a large amount of baking soda into the pan. Then you will let the dough settle for a while before rinsing it off.
• Rinse with clean water: Clean water will help remove leftovers, grease, and baking soda.

After you follow these practical steps, place the broiler pan somewhere so that it dries naturally and is ready for next use.

FAQs

In this part, we will answer some frequently asked questions about these broiler pans. We believe the following feedback will help you.

My Top Pick

In sum, the broiler pan is healthy for cooking with the use of minimal oil and provides great texture to your meals with even heat distribution.

When you buy a broiler pan, make sure you prioritize what you need first. First, go through the features and try to find out if they are really suitable for you to use.

For me, Granite Ware 0513-2 3-Piece Broiler Pan is the best broiler pan because of its healthy cooking properties as well as its excellent nonstick coating. It also distributes heat extremely evenly, and I don’t have to worry that my food can be raw.

Of course, if you need a cheaper alternative, you can always opt for the Nordic Ware 2-Piece Compact Broiler Pan.

How about you? Please comment below to let me know! If you love this post, don’t hesitate to give it a like and share it with other people!