What products are the best cookie jars that I should buy? If this is your concern, keep reading to find out.
We all like the taste of a fragrant cookie, especially those delicious and crunchy fall cookies. And if you feel that cookies and junk food are fun in life, you probably don’t want to bury them with dozens of other foods in the cupboard.
Unless you make cookie mixes in mason jars, you will want to display the cookies on the kitchen counter or the dining table, where everyone in your family can see them.
But a simple plate will not keep your cookies delicious and aromatic for a long time. Then, you need a cookie jar. Cookie jars are created not only to keep junk food fresh and flavorful but also to add personal style to your kitchen.
Therefore, let me go through this article to know more about the best cookie jars for 2023 and give your best choice!
On the market today, there are various types of cookie jar from design to shaping, but the main factor that users care about is the material. Let’s take a look at how many types of cookie jars to determine the best!
Most users prefer the glass jar because of its beauty and toughness. Many also believe that this material makes a good cookie jar.
Your cookie will look classy and bright when stored in glass jars. This material is also safer for health than plastic and metal.
However, you will have to be a little careful not to break the glass jar.
If you like something that looks ancient, a ceramic cookie jar is just for you. Ceramic is also an ideal material to make high-effective garlic keepers. And it is the most vintage material for your kitchen that looks nostalgic.
Ceramic is also diverse in design, design, and color gives you more freedom to choose. Ceramic is also safe for your health.
However, you cannot see the contents inside the ceramic jar but have to open the lid to see it.
Currently, many types of plastic cookie jar designs are as transparent as glass. That means you don’t have to be afraid to break the jar but still own a beautiful shining bottle like a glass jar.
However, when choosing plastic materials, you should also look for reputable manufacturers that ensure quality because plastic can be more toxic than glass or ceramic.
The final is a metal cookie jar for sure lovers. Metal jars are usually coated with a glossy finish with different colors for you to choose.
However, you should carefully choose an anti-rust, stain-resistant metal cookie jar to ensure durability. And you should not wash the metal jar in too hot water because it will damage the jar.
Let’s take a look at my best cookie jars for 2023. You can consult their highlight features to make your best choice.
- Best Overall: OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar
“Unique design, excellent airtight, easy to handle, safe for health, great size.”
- Best Budget: Vinkoe Kitchen Clear Cookie Jar
“Compact and neat, affordable price, great for display, thick wall, easy to wash.”
- Best Quality: Anchor Hocking Montana Glass Jar
“Ideal for storing, classy transparent glass, large capacity, thick walls, and wide mouth.”
- Best Structure: MyGift Round Glass Cookie Jars
“Smart design, safe glass material, effortless control, great for decorating.”
- Best Airtight: Klikel Glass Canister Cookie Jar
“Simple, stylish and convenient, stable, balanced, hard to break, safe and strong.”
- Best Design: Outshine Tin Airtight Cookie Jars
“Anti-rust, anti-corrosion, airtight, eye-catching, safe for health.”
- Best Unique: Doctor Who TARDIS Cookie Jar
“Unique design, impressive high, quality material, easy to clean.”
- Best Decorative: Old Dutch Heritage Cookie Jar
“Large capacity, beautiful copper-plating, fresh-seal technology, convenience countertop.”
- Best Classy: Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jar
“Luxury design, safe material, vintage style, outstanding balance.”
- Best Vintage: Mason Ceramic Cookie Jar
“Keep food fresh, certified food safety, ergonomic lid, a perfect gift.”
Now you can refer to the information in the below chart for the general characteristics of the top 15 best cookie jars for 2023:
|Best Cookie Jars||Dimensions||Weight||Material||Color|
|OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar - Best Overall||7.5 x 5 x 8.5 inches||14.9 ounces||Plastic||Clear|
|Vinkoe Kitchen Clear Cookie Jar - Best Budget||5.67 x 5.51 x 5.35 inches||12.8 ounces||Acrylic||Clear|
|Anchor Hocking Montana Glass Jar - Best Quality||8.62 x 8.62 x 10.2 inches||5 pounds||Glass||Clear|
|MyGift Round Glass Cookie Jars - Best Structure||6.75 x 6.75 x 16 inches||4.4 pounds||Glass||Clear|
|Klikel Glass Canister Cookie Jar - Best Airtight||10.08 x 7.87 x 5.28 inches||3.29 pounds||Glass||Clear|
|Outshine Tin Airtight Cookie Jars - Best Design||8.8 x 8.7 x 8.1 inches||2.4 pounds||Metal||Mint|
|Doctor Who TARDIS Cookie Jar - Best Unique||10 x 5.5 x 5.5 inchesÂ||4.49 pounds||CeramicÂ||Deep Blue|
|Old Dutch Heritage Cookie Jar - Best Decorative||7 x 7 x 9.5 inches||2 pounds||Steel||Copper|
|Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jar - Best Classy||12 x 7 x 7 inches||4 pounds||Ceramic||White|
|Mason Ceramic Cookie Jar - Best Vintage||18 x 11.5 x 7.5 inches||5.49 pounds||Ceramic||Light blue, white lid|
|Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Cookie Jar||12.3 x 8.3 x 7.7 inches||5.34 pounds||Glass||Clear|
|Home Basics Glass Cookie Jar||7.5 x 7.5 x 9.5 inches||1 pound||Glass||Clear|
|KooK Glass Storage Cookie Jars||6.85 x 6.85 x 9.57 inches||6.35 pounds||Glass||Clear|
|Outshine Vintage Cookie Jar||11.85 x 8.31 x 7.8 inches||1.92 pounds||Metal||White with black trim|
|Anchor Hocking Penny Glass Cookie Jar||8.2 x 8.5 x 6.5 inches||3.25 pounds||Glass||Clear|
Below are my particular reviews of the 15 best cookie jars for 2023 and their specific features. Let’s jump into it to get your best cookie jar right away!
Combining the familiar round shape of a cookie jar and a handy pop-up seal, OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar is a new creation! You can also buy a decent jar opener from this brand. Overall, you will love them and their quality.
You can easily access all kinds of cookies and snacks with just one press. OXO Cookie Jar has a unique pop-up mechanism that creates an airtight seal without a screw cap effort.
Besides, this pop-up button also acts as a handle for you to remove the lid with just one hand easily. This cookie jar also has a large round mouth that makes it easy to take out food immediately.
Moreover, the unique shape of this OXO cookie jar allows you to decorate your kitchen while ensuring your food is always fresh. Thanks to the flat surface design to place close to the wall, this OXO cookie jar is neatly displayed and contains more food.
Crafted with high-quality, certified-safety silicone, you don’t have to worry that it will break like glass or rust like metal. OXO POP is precisely the best cookie jar to keep cookies fresh!
- Size of 3-quart great for preserving lots of cookies
- A tremendous pop-up seal design for opening the lid in just one touch
- The airtight function keeps food fresh and delicious
- Excellent after-sale service of OXO: repair/ replace
- Premium silicone material has an extremely high heat resistance
- Design with flat back allows for standing against the wall
- Just press the pop-up button on the lid once to close and open the jar
- The switch is also a handle for smooth operation
- The big mouth makes it easy to access cookies
- Contain more food thanks to smart design
- The seal can be broken
- Overpriced for a plastic jar
- Too light, risking it falling off the edge when unpopped
Specially processed with apothecary acrylic material, Vinkoe Kitchen Clear Cookie Jar looks like glass but is durable and ensures no breakage.
Vinkoe Kitchen Clear Cookie Jar is ideal for storing biscuits, baked goods, sugar, and anything else you like. The lid is also made of the apothecary, which helps preserve the best food.
Besides, this special cookie jar also has a glossy, shimmering look that helps your kitchen glow.
- Acrylic apothecary material is durable but still as beautiful as glass
- Easy to wash at temperatures below 70¨H
- Thickness up to 0.04 inches for resistance to breakage
- Nice, functional and stylish design
- Transparent as glass should display extremely well inside
- Beautifully designed to decorate your kitchen further
- Great for display or storage purposes
- Lids keep confectionery and food fresh for a long time
- Too small size
- No instruction included inside the jar
|Lid type||Acrylic + Silicone seal|
|Dishwasher safe||Yes (under 70H)|
3. Anchor Hocking Montana Glass Jar
Anchor Hocking Jar is made of glass so you can always see what’s inside and how many cookies you have left. The sparkling glass structure also helps you decorate your kitchen more splendidly.
This cookie jar has been specially produced to prevent warping, stain resistance, and odor retention. Moreover, high-quality glass material does not entirely release dangerous chemicals into food.
Smart design with thick walls and a wide mouth, you will quickly put food in and take out food without fear of spillage.
Besides, this jar comes with a matching black aluminum lid with a rubber gasket to keep airtight, ensuring your cookies will stay fresh and retain the flavor when stored there.
The generous 1.5 gallon capacity of Anchor Hocking Montana Glass Jar will help you store anything you need: from cookies, biscuits, candy, coffee to flour, salt, sugar, and spices, etc.
- Made in the USA
- Does not contain BPA
- Ideal for storing a variety of foods
- Glass is safer than plastic and metal
- Made of very classy transparent glass
- Large capacity containing a lot of cookies
- Having a tighter metal lid makes cookies fresher
- The lid is a little tight, so it is difficult to open
- Hand wash recommend
|Dishwasher safe||Yes (not the lid)|
Get to know a few hacks and tricks by watching this video:
MyGift cookie jars are one of the most popular cookie jars, thanks to the spacious and flexible space. This brand is also a famous manufacturer that produces good-grade butter keepers that you can buy to store this ingredient to make cookies.
With an elegant and unique design with three overlapping jars, MyGift Round Glass Cookie Jars is a product you must own to decorate your kitchen.
Because there are three separate storage compartments, this jar is suitable for storing a variety of foods such as cookies, candies, nuts, dried fruits, and a range of other snacks without fear of them and clinging to each other.
Another plus, these jars are made of transparent glass, so they allow you to identify what’s left inside quickly.
This cookie jar will be an excellent gift for your family or close friends!
- 3 tier decorative jar set for large capacity
- Intelligent structure for more space
- Perfect holding every food
- Ideal as a centerpiece at parties
- Up to three floors for storing different types of food without odors
- The safe glass material
- Easily control the amount of food remaining inside
- Great for decorating any space
- Do not wash in the dishwasher
- The glass wall is slightly thin, so it is fragile
The handy Klikel Glass Canister Cookie Jar kit includes two glass containers with metal lids. The lid is very tight thanks to the rubber seal that helps keep the food fresh and taste intact when stored inside.
Should your cookies harden, this airtight jar can help you rectify the issue. The best way to restore your cookies’ softness is by putting a slice of old bread into the jar with your cookies. You’ll have to wait for a day, but I guarantee the results are worth the wait.
Best of all, both jars and lids are FDA-approved, so you can safely use them for long-term food storage.
Besides, like other glass cookie jars, these jars also allow you to see inside to check the number of cookies quickly.
Kikel’s Canister Glass is excellent for storing all kinds of food, including snacks, flour, sugar, and whatever you like.
- Set of 2 airtight cookie jars
- Simple, stylish and convenient
- Lead-free approved by the FDA
- Set of 2 cookie jar ample storage
- Stable, balanced and hard to break
- Safe and strong secure glass for health
- Metal lid with rubber seal keeps food fresh for a long time
- Classy for your kitchen
- The lid will be damaged in the dishwasher
|Size||37oz / 1100ml|
|Lid type||Metal + rubber seal|
|Dishwasher safe||Yes (not the lid)|
With its lovely vintage mint design and outstanding stainless steel trim, Outshine Tin Airtight Cookie Jar is a product you should not ignore. Your kitchen just couldn’t get any cuter with this cookie jar.
Outshine’s airtight function The Airtight Cookie Jar keeps cookies fresh longer. That is thanks to an airtight gasket that can be easily removed.
Moreover, unlike your fears about metal, Outshine Tin Airtight Cookie Jar is intelligently designed with a corrosion-resistant coating that ensures no rust. An individual stainless steel handle will certainly never break.
In particular, comes a heart-shaped cookie mold to create special memories and put in this cute jar.
- FDA recognized safe
- Stunning stainless steel bezel
- The ability to airtight helps keep food intact
- Anti-rust and anti-corrosion coating
- Preserving your cookies comprehensively
- Eye-catching mint color, lovely, outstanding
- Great for decoration or as a gift
- Safe for your health
- Comes with two heart cookie cutters for your creativity
- Not dishwasher safe because metal will swell in hot water
|Lid type||Stainless steel|
Are you searching for a unique cookie jar for the “hard” fan of Doctor Who? The Doctor Who Tardis is just for you.
Finely crafted from high-quality ceramic, light and sound effects when you open or close the lid, The Doctor Who Tardis Cookie Jar is the most exciting cookie jar on the market.
Moreover, Doctor Who Tardis contains an inner plastic box that can be removed to make washing a lot easier.
Doctor Who Tardis is a fun cookie jar that you should not miss!
- Officially licensed BBC Doctor Who merchandises ceramic
- Based on the popular BBC television series
- An impressive 9 inches high for more cookies
- Ideal as a gift, kitchen decor, or addition to the Dr. Who collection.
- Unique and interesting design
- Safe for health ceramic
- Easy to clean thanks to the inner plastic box
- The lid is not tightly closed, so it does not keep cookies fresh for long
Watch this informative video before you buy Doctor Who Tardis:
Are you passionate about things that look classic? So Old Dutch Cookie Jar is the one for you. Your kitchen will be improved with a luxurious classic style.
Talk about the design; this case is decorated with elegant grape-shaped motifs, offering a classic look that suits old-fashioned lovers.
This cookie jar is made from durable steel material and a copper finish with Fresh Seal technology. Besides, the jar comes with a lid with a countertop that fits nicely to keep food fresh for a long time.
With a capacity of 4 liters, this bottle can store quite a lot of snacks and many other dishes. This also makes it easier to wash.
- Beautiful copper-plating
- Fresh-seal technology
- Large 4-quart capacity
- Convenience countertop
- Durable copper material
- Cookies are kept fresh and free from pests.
- The jar is wide and easy to wash
- Keep your food healthy and fresh
- Need to wash by hand and dry immediately
Are you looking for a unique, classy cookie jar? Then Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jar is precisely for you.
The Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jar has an antique-like design, with a luxurious glass knob and embossed ‘cookie’ text. This cookie jar will definitely add to your classy, classy style kitchen.
In particular, Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jar is structured with three small feet to help keep the balance well no matter how much dense food is contained.
Besides, this cookie jar will help keep your cookies fresh for weeks. Thanks to a convenient fitting lid, this jar does a great job keeping food from moisture and pests.
- Convenient rubber seal on the lid
- Unique design with three balanced small legs
- Luxury white ceramic material
- Ideal for vintage style enthusiasts
- Make the kitchen look classy and luxurious
- Outstanding balance with three legs
- Porcelain material keeps cookies safe and fresh
- It is unsafe for dishwashers because the water is very hot and strong detergent reduces color quality
- High price compared to other cookie jars
|Size||12″ x 7″|
|Lid type||Ceramic + Rubber seal|
Mason Ceramic Cookie Jar is a lovely ceramic cookie jar with a lovely light blue color that accentuates your kitchen. Designed with the embossed words “Cookie Mason” helps you quickly identify your unique jars.
Mason Ceramic Cookie Jar is small but can store a lot of cookies and snacks. The vial comes with a handy lid equipped with a silicone gasket, ensuring the flavor and freshness of food for at least a few weeks.
Best of all, all materials of this product are certified for food safety and complete peace of mind to store your small snacks. The jar is made of extremely quality ceramic, so you don’t need to worry about breaking.
- Keep food fresh thanks to tight lids with silicone gaskets
- Create vintage farmhouse look for your kitchen
- Certified food safety
- Designed in the USA
- Store quite a lot of cookies and snacks
- Ergonomic lid with silicone gasket
- Makes a perfect gift for everyone
- A little bit small
- If you want to keep the color like new, you need to wash it by hand
|Color||Light blue, white lid|
When you buy this product, you get up to two great cookie jars. This jar made of high-quality glass comes with a rubber gasket lid, keeping your food fresh.
Smartly designed, this jar gives us maximum storage space thanks to straight edges and easy control because of the transparent glass.
You can use this jar on any occasion: at parties, meetings, camps, or home. This is the perfect jar for all types of biscuits, candies, snacks, coffee, beans, flour, sugar. No need to worry, your food will be kept safe for long in this jar.
This cookie jar keeps your kitchen looking beautiful and beautiful. You can freely choose the one you love and put it on the table, in the office, in the kitchen, or any position you like.
- Set of 2 quality cookie jars
- Two-way stability structure
- Extra storage space
- BPA free, lead-free, quality glass
- Design with straight edges to save more space
- Metal lid with sealed silicon helps airtight
- Create an eye-catching kitchen
- Great gift for cookie lovers or those who like to be organized
- Wide enough for all your needs
- Metal lids must be washed by hands
|Lid type||Metal + Silicone seal|
|Dishwasher safe||Yes (not the lid)|
Home Basics Large Glass Cookie Jar is a classic glass jar to store your food. On the other hand, you can consider buying this brand’s elegant napkin holders too. These products will surely make your kitchen look more aesthetic.
This large-capacity jar is made of transparent glass, comes with a decorative label with the word ‘cookie’ to make your kitchen look more lively.
Because it’s made of glass, Home Basics Large Glass Cookie Jar allows you to look inside easily and at all times, so you don’t have to bother opening each lid to see how much food is left there.
With its large size, this cookie jar can store not only biscuits and also sugar, spices, cereals, etc.
This Home Basics jar is also easy to clean and tidy because it is safe for dishwashers. But you should wash the lid by hand to avoid rust.
- Large capacity up to 7.5-Inch by 10-Inch
- Tightly fitting metal lids help cookies stay fresh longer
- Glass material is safe for health
- Add a beautiful decor to your kitchen
- Colossal capacity to hold everything comfortably
- Multifunctional, can accommodate cookies, sugar, candy, cereal, pasta, etc.
- Wide mouth for easy scooping, easy to clean
- The lid is insecure with dishwasher
|Size||7.5-inch by 10-inch|
|Dishwasher safe||Yes (not the lid)|
Kook Glass Storage is a set of two classic glass cookie jars, convenient and perfect for all types of dry confectionery. You can freely choose to store different dishes or even spices.
In particular, even the lid is made of glass to ensure aesthetics, and you can always easily see your cookies inside. This clean, sleek look is perfect for a party or simply makes your home more sparkling.
Moreover, the glass lid is equipped with a plastic gasket around, which creates a very tight seal, ensuring the food inside is always fresh.
1/2 gallon capacity is suitable for the average household, ensuring you have enough cookie storage space that is still compact and easy to store.
- Two cookie jars in 1 set
- Great for storing cookies, baked goods, sugar, salt, etc.
- Dishwasher safe
- Compact, easy to store
- Luxurious appearance polished from seal to body
- Suitable for partying or decorating the kitchen more beautiful
- Keep food fresh for long
- The lid is not really tight
This is a cookie jar that gives a vintage feel to any space that holds it. With a pure white color and a delicate black border and sophisticated “Cookies”, Outshine Vintage Cookie Jar is a cookie jar that fans of vintage style cannot ignore.
Not only has the unique appearance, but Outshine Vintage Cookie Jar also has an airtight gasket that can also be removed, making it easier to handle, and your baking is also much longer.
Outshine Vintage Cookie Jar is meticulously machined for impressive durability. You will never worry about rust or broken handles. Thanks to the particular anti-corrosion casing and sturdy metal handle, this cookie jar will follow you for a long time.
- FDA tested for food safety
- Ideal for housewarming, wedding gifts
- Finish layer against rust and corrosion
- Airtight seal keeps food fresh
- Classic style and premium feeling
- Exquisite with the hand-painted vintage trims
- Safe for health whether made of metal
- Not afraid of broken like glass
- Convenient and firm handle
- Slightly small
- Unsafe in the dishwasher
|Lid type||Metal + Gasket|
Anchor Hocking Penny Glass Jar is a set of two fashionable cookie jars.
These two cookie jars are made of quality glass, with thick edges to ensure durability and stability, ensuring long-term survival.
Being able to see through is a plus for these cookie jars. You can quickly check the amount of bread inside.
Besides, the jars are provided with chrome fitting lids, ensuring the food you store in it is always fresh.
- One set contains two jars with chrome lids
- Keep cookies fresh for longer
- No BPA and other hazardous substances
- American made glass
- Perfect for storing dry goods like flour, biscuits, coffee, spices, candies, etc.
- Made of luxurious transparent glass
- Strong and durable structure
- Wide mouth and thick wall helps prevent shedding, easy scraping
- Safe for health with quality glass material
- Metal lids should be washed by hand to prevent rust
|Dishwasher safe||Yes (not the lid)|
Check out this video for more useful tips:
You are still wondering what cookie jar to buy? So consider the following feature factors to choose the best suitable cookie jar for you:
If you already want a cookie jar, you’re interested in how it looks and makes your kitchen look more delicate. Determine what style you want to pursue and choose the cookie jar with the most appropriate design: classic, vintage, luxurious, dull, or unique in your own way.
If you like the premium feel, choose a glass or metal cookie jar. If you’re a bit careless, choose plastic or silicone. If you are a nostalgic person, choose a ceramic cookie jar.
This is an essential part of whether your cookie jar is airtight or not. Choose a cookie jar with an airtight lid to keep your cookies for as long as possible.
Lids with plastic or silicone layers are more secure. Or there is a convenient and enjoyable pop-up lid format for you.
In any case, your family’s health is above all else. Please choose the cookie jar that is certified to be safe to use.
This is equally important. I am going to list out some popular cookie jar brands on the market below that may help you take a quick glance when you’re shopping:
- Anchor Hocking: Has been established since 1905, Anchor Hocking commits producing innovative cookie jar in particular and glassware in general. Nordic Ware prides itself on glass household products made in the US.
- OXO: Has been in the market for over 30 years, OXO’s goal is to bring customers creative jars, inspiring, and having fun in your kitchen. OXO is continuously evolving to match the latest trends and tastes.
- Home Basics: Travels around the world, searching for the fabrication techniques, newest trends, and innovations to provide customers with cutting-edge fashion cookie jars.
Here are some common questions and answers about cookie jars, you can read to understand more and find out the best knowledge for yourself!
My Top Pick
To conclude, OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar is definitely the best cookie jar for someone who loves creativity and agility like me.
This is the smartest, most creative pop-up cookie jar I’ve ever seen. OXO’s convenient lid also ensures airtight to keep cookies fresh as long as possible.
Besides, although not made of glass, OXO looks not inferior to glass with a transparent and luxurious appearance that will brighten up your kitchen.
Moreover, the plastic material of OXO is exceptionally advanced and proven safe, best for your health.
How about you? Don’t hesitate to share about your best cookie jar below!
Table of Contents
- Popular Cookies Jars’ Materials Classification
- Which Are The Best Cookie Jars To Buy?
- Cookie Jar Comparison Table 2023
- Top 15 Best Cookie Jar Reviews in 2023
- 1. OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar
- 2. Vinkoe Kitchen Clear Cookie Jar
- 3. Anchor Hocking Montana Glass Jar
- 4. MyGift Round Glass Cookie Jars
- 5. Klikel Glass Canister Cookie Jar
- 6. Outshine Tin Airtight Cookie Jars
- 7. Doctor Who TARDIS Cookie Jar
- 8. Old Dutch Heritage Cookie Jar
- 9. Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jar
- 10. Mason Ceramic Cookie Jar
- 11. Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Cookie Jar
- 12. Home Basics Glass Cookie Jar
- 13. KooK Glass Storage Cookie Jars
- 14. Outshine Vintage Cookie Jar
- 15. Anchor Hocking Penny Glass Cookie Jar
- Finding The Best Cookie Jar To Buy
- My Top Pick
Leave a Reply